SmartProfitFX vs iA Private Wealth
iA Private Wealth Inc. is the active Canadian dealer. CIRO records the old-name chain from McFarlane Gordon Inc. to MGI Securities, then Industrial Alliance Securities Inc., and finally iA Private Wealth. Current iA documents, not old MGI forex statements, control this comparison.
Also searched as: iA Gestion privée de patrimoine inc., iA Private Wealth Inc., iaprivatewealth.ca, Industrial Alliance Private Wealth, Industrial Alliance Securities Inc., Industrielle Alliance Valeurs mobilières Inc., McFarlane Gordon Inc., MGI, MGI Securities, MGI Securities Inc., mgisecurities.com, www.mgisecurities.com
Verdict
These are materially different services. SmartProfitFX is an Eightcap-powered CFD account-opening route for eligible non-U.S. traders; iA Private Wealth is an advisor-led Canadian wealth-management dealer offering advisory and managed accounts. MGI Securities belongs only to iA's historical name lineage.
For an eligible Eightcap-powered CFD setup
Choose this route only if the Eightcap-powered platform, CFD market scope and current regional eligibility fit, and the SmartProfitFX commission difference matters after reviewing current Eightcap terms.
For Canadian advisor-led wealth management
iA may fit Canadian clients seeking commission-based or fee-based advisory accounts, managed accounts, registered plans, investment-dealer products and financial-planning support through an Investment Advisor or Portfolio Manager.
Do not compare old MGI forex terms
MGI Securities is historical lineage, not a current forex account option. Compare SmartProfitFX only with iA's current advisor-led service, current fee documents, applicable dealer registration and live account eligibility.
Quick comparison
Research checked 2026-06-10. Broker terms can change; verify current official documents before opening or funding an account.
| Category | SmartProfitFX powered by Eightcap | iA Private Wealth |
|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Eligible non-U.S. traders who want the SmartProfitFX account setup powered by Eightcap, including Eightcap-powered platform, market, funding and support context plus the $1 lower round-trip commission versus opening directly with Eightcap. | account and onboarding material was checked in the broker-owned source set dated 2026-06-04. account fit should be matched to the live application path, required documents and account terms before funding. |
| Account setup | SmartProfitFX is an account-opening option powered by Eightcap, not the regulated broker. The account relationship depends on current Eightcap documents and eligibility rules. | The current client relationship disclosure separates advisory accounts, managed accounts, third-party managed accounts, and separately or unified managed account programs. Advisory accounts can be commission-based or fee-based; managed-account decisions are made on a discretionary basis by a Portfolio Manager. Current non-registered account types include cash, margin, option, short sale, DAP/RAP and high-interest savings accounts, with several types limited to the Investment Dealer. Current registered-account material includes RRSP, locked-in plans, TFSA, FHSA, RESP, RDSP, RRIF and individual pension plans. |
| Pricing and spreads | Eightcap-powered terms should be checked through current Eightcap documents; SmartProfitFX adds a $1 lower round-trip commission than opening directly with Eightcap where applicable. | The current client relationship disclosure says commission-based advisory accounts pay a commission on every purchase or sale, while fee-based accounts pay an annual flat-dollar fee and/or a percentage of account market value. Managed-account and third-party-managed-account fees depend on the applicable agreement and assets under management. The published administration and service fee schedule is effective January 2025 and says standard fees may be taxable and can vary by account or program. Examples in the January 2025 schedule include $125 per year for RSP/LIRA/spousal RSP and RIF/LIF accounts, $50 per year for a TFSA, and $175 per account for a transfer to another institution. Current fees must be checked with the Investment Advisor because negotiated account charges, product costs, commissions, markups, taxes and third-party costs can apply. |
| Commissions and fees | The SmartProfitFX pricing point is the $1 lower round-trip commission versus opening directly with Eightcap, after confirming the account type and region. | The current client relationship disclosure says commission-based advisory accounts pay a commission on every purchase or sale, while fee-based accounts pay an annual flat-dollar fee and/or a percentage of account market value. Managed-account and third-party-managed-account fees depend on the applicable agreement and assets under management. The published administration and service fee schedule is effective January 2025 and says standard fees may be taxable and can vary by account or program. Examples in the January 2025 schedule include $125 per year for RSP/LIRA/spousal RSP and RIF/LIF accounts, $50 per year for a TFSA, and $175 per account for a transfer to another institution. Current fees must be checked with the Investment Advisor because negotiated account charges, product costs, commissions, markups, taxes and third-party costs can apply. |
| Platforms | SmartProfitFX users should verify current Eightcap-powered platform availability, including MetaTrader and TradingView-style workflows where available. | iA Private Wealth provides a client portal and mobile app for reviewing portfolios, documents and interactions with an advisor. The current access page describes account-viewing and document access; it should not be described as a self-directed forex or CFD trading platform. Old MGI directory statements about MetaTrader or forex trading are not supported by the current iA source set and must not be reused. |
| Markets | Eightcap states broad CFD market access; eligible SmartProfitFX users should confirm the live Eightcap-powered market list for their account and region. | The Mutual Fund Dealer product list includes prospectus mutual funds, principal-protected notes, GICs, liquid alternative mutual funds and ETFs. The Investment Dealer route supports a broader product set, including fixed-income securities and equities, subject to account, registration and advisor suitability requirements. The solutions page presents portfolio management, tax-efficient investing, insurance, retirement, estate and education planning. Availability depends on the dealer registration, account type, product, advisor and client circumstances. |
| Entity and regulation | SmartProfitFX should not be presented as the regulated broker; check the applicable Eightcap entity and legal documents. | iA Private Wealth is a trademark and business name under which iA Private Wealth Inc. operates. CIRO says McFarlane Gordon Inc. was founded in 2000 and re-branded as MGI Securities in 2005. CIRO says Jovian, and therefore MGI, was acquired by Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial Services Inc. in October 2013. CIRO says MGI Securities was amalgamated with Industrial Alliance Securities Inc. on 1 April 2014. CIRO says Industrial Alliance Securities Inc. changed its name to iA Private Wealth Inc. effective 18 January 2021. MGI Securities is historical lineage for the current iA Private Wealth dealer, not a separate active account-opening brand. The current homepage says iA Private Wealth Inc. is a member of the Canadian Investor Protection Fund and the Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization. The current client account agreement says iA Private Wealth Inc. has Investment Dealer and Mutual Fund Dealer registrations under securities legislation in all Canadian jurisdictions. CIRO's current dealer list includes iA Private Wealth Inc. The current regulatory framework says iA Private Wealth may open accounts only in countries, provinces and territories where it is registered. Historical MGI Securities or Industrial Alliance Securities names do not represent separate current licences. |
| Funding | Check current Eightcap-powered deposit and withdrawal methods, processing times, fees and region rules before funding. | funding or cash-movement material was checked where the broker-owned source set made it available. Any bank, cash movement, currency, transfer or withdrawal charge should be verified before funding. |
| Eligibility and risk | SmartProfitFX eligibility follows current SmartProfitFX and Eightcap restrictions, including non-U.S. availability limits. | The current website describes iA Private Wealth as wealth management tailored for Canadians. The regulatory framework limits account opening to jurisdictions where iA Private Wealth is registered. The account agreement says moving outside Canada can limit available services and may require an account to be closed. Readers outside Canada should not infer eligibility from the historical MGI name or old website. The client relationship disclosure says higher potential performance requires accepting associated risk and that high-return, low-risk investments do not exist. The account agreement says margin is a loan that adds risk and must be repaid with interest even if purchased securities decline. The account agreement says short selling has unlimited risk and can result in significant losses. Model or managed-portfolio returns may differ from actual performance, and past performance is not indicative of future performance. The best-execution disclosure says over-the-counter prices can include a markup or markdown, commission and service charges. |
iA Private Wealth source-checked research brief
The notes below use current iA Private Wealth documents and CIRO records. They separate present-day accounts, fees, registration and risk from the historical MGI Securities name.
Account setup and onboarding facts
- The current client relationship disclosure separates advisory accounts, managed accounts, third-party managed accounts, and separately or unified managed account programs.
- Advisory accounts can be commission-based or fee-based; managed-account decisions are made on a discretionary basis by a Portfolio Manager.
- Current non-registered account types include cash, margin, option, short sale, DAP/RAP and high-interest savings accounts, with several types limited to the Investment Dealer.
- Current registered-account material includes RRSP, locked-in plans, TFSA, FHSA, RESP, RDSP, RRIF and individual pension plans.
- The current client relationship disclosure says commission-based advisory accounts pay a commission on every purchase or sale, while fee-based accounts pay an annual flat-dollar fee and/or a percentage of account market value.
- Managed-account and third-party-managed-account fees depend on the applicable agreement and assets under management.
- The published administration and service fee schedule is effective January 2025 and says standard fees may be taxable and can vary by account or program.
- Examples in the January 2025 schedule include $125 per year for RSP/LIRA/spousal RSP and RIF/LIF accounts, $50 per year for a TFSA, and $175 per account for a transfer to another institution.
- Current fees must be checked with the Investment Advisor because negotiated account charges, product costs, commissions, markups, taxes and third-party costs can apply.
Spreads, commissions and fee context
- pricing material was checked in current broker-owned cost, market or service pages available for this review.
- costs should be checked by product, market, order channel, account type and service before trading.
- Any cost examples on this page are treated as date-checked facts from the listed broker-owned pages or documents.
- commission or trading-charge material was checked for the current broker review.
- Exchange, tax, custody, transfer, financing, currency and third-party costs should be checked against iA Private Wealth's current documents.
- Use live official pages for spread, commission and fee checks because trading costs can change without notice.
Platforms, markets and instruments
- iA Private Wealth provides a client portal and mobile app for reviewing portfolios, documents and interactions with an advisor.
- The current access page describes account-viewing and document access; it should not be described as a self-directed forex or CFD trading platform.
- Old MGI directory statements about MetaTrader or forex trading are not supported by the current iA source set and must not be reused.
- The Mutual Fund Dealer product list includes prospectus mutual funds, principal-protected notes, GICs, liquid alternative mutual funds and ETFs.
- The Investment Dealer route supports a broader product set, including fixed-income securities and equities, subject to account, registration and advisor suitability requirements.
- The solutions page presents portfolio management, tax-efficient investing, insurance, retirement, estate and education planning.
- Availability depends on the dealer registration, account type, product, advisor and client circumstances.
Legal route, restrictions and client scope
- iA Private Wealth is a trademark and business name under which iA Private Wealth Inc. operates.
- CIRO says McFarlane Gordon Inc. was founded in 2000 and re-branded as MGI Securities in 2005.
- CIRO says Jovian, and therefore MGI, was acquired by Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial Services Inc. in October 2013.
- CIRO says MGI Securities was amalgamated with Industrial Alliance Securities Inc. on 1 April 2014.
- CIRO says Industrial Alliance Securities Inc. changed its name to iA Private Wealth Inc. effective 18 January 2021.
- MGI Securities is historical lineage for the current iA Private Wealth dealer, not a separate active account-opening brand.
- The current homepage says iA Private Wealth Inc. is a member of the Canadian Investor Protection Fund and the Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization.
- The current client account agreement says iA Private Wealth Inc. has Investment Dealer and Mutual Fund Dealer registrations under securities legislation in all Canadian jurisdictions.
- CIRO's current dealer list includes iA Private Wealth Inc.
- The current regulatory framework says iA Private Wealth may open accounts only in countries, provinces and territories where it is registered.
- Historical MGI Securities or Industrial Alliance Securities names do not represent separate current licences.
- The current website describes iA Private Wealth as wealth management tailored for Canadians.
- The regulatory framework limits account opening to jurisdictions where iA Private Wealth is registered.
- The account agreement says moving outside Canada can limit available services and may require an account to be closed.
- Readers outside Canada should not infer eligibility from the historical MGI name or old website.
Funding workflow and risk warnings
- The client relationship disclosure says higher potential performance requires accepting associated risk and that high-return, low-risk investments do not exist.
- The account agreement says margin is a loan that adds risk and must be repaid with interest even if purchased securities decline.
- The account agreement says short selling has unlimited risk and can result in significant losses.
- Model or managed-portfolio returns may differ from actual performance, and past performance is not indicative of future performance.
- The best-execution disclosure says over-the-counter prices can include a markup or markdown, commission and service charges.
- A 2021 CIRO/IIROC settlement decision says iA Private Wealth failed to establish and maintain a reasonably designed supervisory system for the conduct described in that decision.
- The decision describes unsuitable recommendations, high concentration and trading volumes in small issuers, and improper use of margin in the historical underlying activity.
- The decision says iA Private Wealth self-reported, investigated, settled with a number of complainants, revised policies and procedures, and implemented a new compliance structure.
- The accepted settlement imposed a $350,000 fine and $25,000 in costs.
- This is historical regulatory context and should not be generalized into an unsupported statement about every current advisor or account.
iA Private Wealth caveats
These caveats keep the comparison useful without overstating what the iA Private Wealth official sources prove.
Current pages, not directory summaries
The iA Private Wealth side is based on official pages fetched for this brief. Discovery-directory descriptions should not be reused as page facts.
Match the account-opening entity
A broker brand can route clients through different legal entities. Confirm the entity, licence or registration and country restrictions in the live onboarding flow.
Pricing and fees can change
Treat brokerage, spread, commission, swap and funding examples as date-checked source facts, not permanent promises.
Trading and margin can create losses
The comparison does not reduce trading risk. Review leverage, margin, client-money, negative-balance and loss-risk wording where those topics apply before opening or funding an account.
MGI Securities is historical iA lineage
CIRO documents the sequence from McFarlane Gordon Inc. to MGI Securities, its 2014 amalgamation with Industrial Alliance Securities, and the 2021 name change to iA Private Wealth. Do not treat MGI as a separate active broker.
Advisor-led wealth management, not old MGI forex
Current iA sources describe advisory and managed accounts, Canadian investment and mutual-fund dealer registrations, and a client portal/mobile app. They do not support republishing old MGI forex, MetaTrader, spread or leverage statements.
Read the 2021 CIRO decision precisely
The decision records a historical supervisory failure and sanctions, while also saying the firm self-reported, investigated, settled with a number of complainants, revised policies and implemented a new compliance structure.
Who should choose which?
Choose based on service model and jurisdiction: an eligible Eightcap-powered CFD route versus current Canadian advisor-led wealth management.
- You are eligible outside the United States and want the SmartProfitFX account setup powered by Eightcap.
- You want an Eightcap-powered CFD trading workflow rather than an advisor-led Canadian wealth-management relationship.
- You have checked the current Eightcap entity, platforms, instruments, pricing, funding terms and risk disclosures.
- The SmartProfitFX commission difference matters after account and platform fit are clear.
- You are eligible for iA Private Wealth's Canadian advisor-led account-opening route.
- You want commission-based or fee-based advice, discretionary managed-account options, registered plans or broader wealth-planning support.
- You have reviewed the applicable Investment Dealer or Mutual Fund Dealer product scope and current account agreement.
- You accept the applicable investment, margin, short-selling, product, fee and advisor-suitability risks.
FAQs
Is SmartProfitFX better than iA Private Wealth?
SmartProfitFX is the better fit only when you are eligible for the SmartProfitFX account setup powered by Eightcap and you prefer that platform, market, funding and support context before weighing the $1 lower round-trip commission than opening directly with Eightcap.
Which old iA Private Wealth names does this page cover?
It covers CIRO-supported historical names including McFarlane Gordon Inc., MGI Securities and Industrial Alliance Securities Inc. Industrial Alliance Private Wealth is retained only as a search variation; current legal and account facts come from iA Private Wealth Inc.
What did the iA Private Wealth source review cover?
The review checked 12 primary-source URLs on 2026-06-10: current iA account, product, fee, portal, regulatory, eligibility and risk documents plus CIRO records that establish the MGI Securities lineage and current dealer status.
What is the main iA Private Wealth diligence point?
The main diligence point is to match iA Private Wealth's live account-opening entity with the official legal, eligibility and risk language, especially where broker pages mention regulated entities, country restrictions, leverage, margin or loss risk.
Can U.S. traders use this page as account-opening advice?
No. SmartProfitFX eligibility follows current SmartProfitFX and Eightcap restrictions, including non-U.S. availability limits. iA Private Wealth eligibility must be verified from the broker's current official pages before account opening.
Why does the page include source dates?
Broker terms can change. Source dates show when account, pricing, platform, legal, eligibility and risk pages were checked so readers know what still needs live confirmation.
What happened to MGI Securities?
CIRO says McFarlane Gordon Inc. became MGI Securities in 2005, MGI was amalgamated with Industrial Alliance Securities Inc. on 1 April 2014, and Industrial Alliance Securities Inc. changed its name to iA Private Wealth Inc. effective 18 January 2021. MGI is not a separate current broker.
What account models does iA Private Wealth currently offer?
Its current client relationship disclosure describes commission-based and fee-based advisory accounts, managed accounts, third-party managed accounts, and SMA/UMA programs, plus multiple non-registered and registered account types. Availability depends on the applicable dealer route and client circumstances.
What iA Private Wealth fees should readers verify?
Verify commissions or percentage fees agreed with the advisor, managed-account fees, product costs, markups or markdowns, taxes, and the date-specific administration schedule. The published January 2025 schedule includes examples such as $125 annual RSP/RIF fees, a $50 TFSA fee and a $175 outbound account-transfer fee.
Sources checked
Source date: 2026-06-10. Primary sources below were checked 2026-06-10. Current iA documents control present-day account, fee, eligibility and risk facts; CIRO records control the MGI name history.
- Current iA Private Wealth homepage: iaprivatewealth.ca/
- Current client relationship disclosure: files.iaprivatewealth.ca/-/media/files/iaprivatewealth/pdf/en/client-relationship-disclosure-en.pdf
- Current client account agreement: iaprivatewealth.ca/-/media/files/iaprivatewealth/documents/en/external/pdf/welcome-package.pdf
- Current administration and service fees: files.iaprivatewealth.ca/-/media/files/iaprivatewealth/documents/en/external/pdf/administration-fees-2024.pdf
- Current regulatory framework: iaprivatewealth.ca/regulatory-framework
- Current account portal and mobile app access: iaprivatewealth.ca/access
- Current best-execution disclosure: iaprivatewealth.ca/regulatory-framework/best-execution-disclosure
- CIRO MGI-to-iA lineage and enforcement decision: www.ciro.ca/media/3421/download
- CIRO current dealer list: www.ciro.ca/media/12811/download?inline=
Related comparisons
Use these related comparisons to check the SmartProfitFX/Eightcap context and compare other broker source trails.
Compare the sources before opening
If SmartProfitFX powered by Eightcap is the better fit, use the SmartProfitFX account link so the account opens through SmartProfitFX.